How Much Should I Offer for an Investment Property?

··7 min read

The asking price in the listing is the seller's wish. As an investor, you need to answer a different question: Up to what price does the property still make financial sense? If you do not know that number, you bid on gut feeling and can easily overpay in a bidding process. In this article, we show you how to calculate your maximum bid for an investment property in Switzerland, using two simple limits you can explain to any bank and any broker.

Why the Asking Price Is Not Your Number

Sellers and brokers usually set the price based on comparable prices per m²: What have similar apartments in the municipality sold for recently? That makes sense for owner-occupiers. For an investment property, however, the price per square metre tells you little. Two apartments with the same price per m² can have completely different yields, because rent, condition, running costs and vacancy risk differ.

As an investor, you are not buying square metres, you are buying a stream of rental income. The right price therefore comes from that stream, not from the house next door.

Limit 1: The Price at Which Cash Flow Turns Negative

The first limit is the most important: Up to what purchase price does the property pay for itself? In other words: net rent minus interest, amortisation, owner's running costs, maintenance and vacancy comes to at least zero.

Every additional franc on the purchase price drives up several costs at once:

  • The mortgage gets bigger. At the same loan-to-value (for example 75%), it grows in proportion, and so does the interest.
  • The 2nd mortgage grows too. Anything above 66.7% loan-to-value usually has to be amortised within 15 years. That hits cash flow directly.
  • Purchase costs rise. Property transfer tax, notary and land registry fees are percentage-based in most cantons.
  • Maintenance rises. Many investors budget 0.8 to 1% of the purchase price per year.

The rent, on the other hand, stays the same. So somewhere there is a price at which monthly cash flow is exactly zero. Above it, you top up every month out of your own pocket. We call this price cash-flow neutral.

How to Find the Cash-Flow-Neutral Price

Run the numbers on the property at the asking price. If cash flow is positive, raise the price step by step until it reaches zero. If it is negative, lower it. Important: loan-to-value, interest rate and maintenance rate stay the same. You only change the price.

Doing this by hand is tedious, because interest, amortisation and costs shift with every step. In the immometrics analysis tool, the "Negotiation room" section calculates exactly this automatically.

Limit 2: The Price That Delivers the Market Yield

The second limit compares the property with the market: At what price does it reach the gross yield that is typical in the canton?

The formula is simple:

Price for target yield = annual rent ÷ target yield

With an annual rent of CHF 31'800 and a typical gross yield of 3.25%, that is CHF 31'800 ÷ 0.0325 = roughly CHF 978'000.

If the asking price is higher, you are paying more than the market charges for comparable yields. If it is lower, the property is cheap from a yield perspective. The canton comparison shows you which yield is typical in your canton. We explain how gross yield, net yield and return on equity fit together in Gross Yield vs. Net Yield vs. Return on Equity.

Worked Example: Apartment in Zurich for CHF 890'000

Let us take a 4.5-room apartment in the canton of Zurich:

AssumptionValue
Asking priceCHF 890'000
Floor area105 m²
Net rentCHF 2'650 per month
Mortgage80% loan-to-value
Maintenance0.8% of purchase price per year
Vacancy2%

This gives us the two limits:

  • Cash-flow neutral up to CHF 852'000. That is about 4% below the asking price. At the asking price, you therefore top up a little every month.
  • Market yield (3.25%) up to CHF 978'000. That is about 10% above the asking price. From a yield perspective, the property is therefore not expensive.

What does this mean for the negotiation? The price is fair compared with the market, but with the chosen financing the property does not quite pay for itself. You have three options:

  1. Negotiate down to around CHF 850'000. Then the property pays for itself with your financing.
  2. Put in more equity. With a lower loan-to-value, interest and amortisation fall, and the cash-flow-neutral price rises.
  3. Accept topping up on purpose. If you are betting on capital growth and amortisation, slightly negative cash flow can be justified. But then you should know how much it is per month and for how long.

What Moves Your Maximum Bid

The two limits are not laws of nature. These levers move them the most:

  • Interest rate. One percentage point more interest lowers the cash-flow-neutral price significantly. So always also run the numbers with a rate rise of 2 percentage points. More on this in SARON or Fixed-Rate Mortgage.
  • Loan-to-value. Less debt means a higher cash-flow-neutral price, but also more equity tied up.
  • Rent and tenant turnover. If the current rent is below market level, a change of tenant can improve cash flow later. But do not count on it happening tomorrow.
  • Condition. A renovation backlog eats into your margin. For older properties, set maintenance at 1% or higher.
  • Taxes. Rental income increases your taxable income. By how much depends on the canton: Taxes on Investment Properties.

And the Bank?

Your maximum bid is only useful if the bank goes along with it. So check affordability in parallel. The bank calculates with an imputed interest rate of around 5%, not with the current market rate. A property can therefore be cash-flow positive and still fail the affordability test.

A well-prepared dossier with purchase price, financing, cash flow and forecast helps in your meeting with the bank. How to get the best possible terms is covered in Negotiating a Mortgage for Investment Properties.

Conclusion

Before you make an offer, you should know two numbers:

  1. The cash-flow-neutral price: Up to this point, the property pays for itself with your financing.
  2. The price for the market yield: Up to this point, you are not paying more than the market.

If the asking price is below both, you have room to go higher if it comes to a bidding process. If it is above both, negotiating is a must, or the property is not for you.

immometrics calculates both numbers for every listing: paste the link, check the financing, and read them off in the "Negotiation room" section.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I open with my maximum bid?

No. Your maximum bid is your ceiling, not your first offer. Start lower and back up your offer with numbers: rent, maintenance, interest rate risk. Sellers respond better to arguments they can follow than to a number pulled out of thin air.

What do I do in a bidding process?

Set your ceiling before the first bid and write it down. In a bidding process the pressure rises, and that is exactly when clear limits help. If the price goes above it, let the property go. Others will come along.

Does this also apply to multi-family buildings?

Yes, the logic is the same. With multi-family buildings, it is also worth comparing the rent for each apartment with the market and estimating vacancy realistically. Our checklist for buying an investment property helps with this.

Official sources and further reading

Calculate the return on your property now

Free. No registration required.

Analyze now